Federal High Court in Abuja has dismissed a suit filed by Chief Momoh Yusuf Obaro challenging the emergence of former Kogi State Governor, Yahaya Bello, as the winner of the May 2026 Kogi Central senatorial primary election.
Delivering judgment on Thursday, Justice Inyang Ekwo ruled that the plaintiff had failed to exhaust his political party’s internal dispute resolution mechanisms before approaching the court.
The judge also held that the documentary evidence presented by Obaro was unsigned and therefore lacked probative value.
Court cites failure to exhaust party remedies
Justice Ekwo said Obaro had undertaken, upon joining the party and participating in its primary election, not to institute legal action without first exhausting the party’s internal dispute resolution procedures.
According to the party’s guidelines, aggrieved members are required to explore all available channels within the party structure before seeking judicial intervention.
The court acknowledged that Obaro had initially complied with the procedure by submitting a petition to the Appeal Committee.
However, it said he failed to take the next mandatory step of appealing to the National Working Committee (NWC), as required by Paragraph 15(3) of the party’s constitution.
“By rushing straight to court without approaching the NWC, the Plaintiff bypassed a mandatory condition precedent. Consequently, I resolve this issue in favour of the 1st Defendant (INEC) and the 2nd Defendant (Yahaya Bello),” the judge held.
Judge faults unsigned documents
Examining the documentary evidence relating to the primary election across the five local government areas of Kogi Central, Justice Ekwo noted that none of the exhibits bore the signature of the chairman or secretary of the electoral committee that conducted the exercise.
The documents were tendered as Exhibits Obaro Ajaokuta (1)–(12), Obaro Okene (1)–(12), Obaro Ogori (1)–(10), Obaro Adavi (1)–(12) and Obaro Okehi (1)–(12).
The judge said whoever supplied the documents to the plaintiff had misled him and given him false hope.
He added that even though Obaro was not a lawyer, he ought to have consulted his counsel before presenting the documents to the court.
“Take it that the Plaintiff is not a lawyer, but he should have taken a step to consult his lawyer before dumping these documents on the court. These unsigned documents submitted by the Plaintiff are of dubious origin,” Justice Ekwo stated.
Court dismisses suit
Obaro had commenced the substantive suit through an originating summons filed on 28 May 2026, accompanied by a written address dated 29 May.
He had asked the court to declare him the authentic winner of the Kogi Central senatorial primary.
However, counsel to the second defendant, J.B. Daudu, SAN, urged the court to uphold his preliminary objection and dismiss the suit.
Justice Ekwo subsequently dismissed the action for lacking merit and ordered all parties to bear their respective costs.
Reacting to the judgment outside the courtroom, defence counsel described the verdict as sound, thorough and well-reasoned.
“We commend the learned trial judge for his erudite and painstaking judgment, which has upheld the sanctity of the law and the democratic process.
“The dismissal of this suit comes as no surprise, as the plaintiff merely embarked on a speculative voyage, seeking from the bench a victory he failed to secure from the electorate.
“Our candidate’s triumph at the primary election was the product of an overwhelming endorsement by the people, and we are gratified that the court has given judicial validation to that clear mandate,” he said.
RN